Nico's Pizza - New Britain, Pennsylvania

Robert M.

Muy bueno

Stephanie B.

It’s always so nice coming to Nico’s. We used to live right around the corner but we’ve moved an hour away so now it’s a treat for us to come here. They give you such a familial feeling to everyone, regulars or one timers! The food is always amazing and the garlic knots are divine. If you haven’t been here and you’re thinking about it, I recommend 100%!

Sky J.

Editing review to 5 stars. Nico's actually responded to my review and showed they value feedback and their customers. I mean, I already rated them good, but just giving them some extra praise since they took the time to reach out and thank me for stopping in.

Two Words: Spaghetti Balls.

The pizza is good. The canolli is great.
But the spaghetti balls are AMAZING. The staff is very nice here and the restaurant is comfortable and clean. They usually have pizza out for pick up and garlic knots. I think the prices are reasonable as well. I would recommend this place for a quick bite or sit down meal.

DVC R.

It takes something special for a pizzeria to WOW me. Walked in... Greeted by their staff. Restaurant was clean. Tables were set up nicely.
I tried something NEW... PINWHEELS... I highly recommend these incredible little meat and cheese filled rolls!!!

I can't wait for another visit to try the sandwiches!

Kyle C.

They have the best pizza in town!! There is something about the dough that will leave you craving more! Give them a try and you’ll see what I mean! Their wraps and spaghetti balls are also a hit but just about everything I’ve had there always is!! Thank you!

Tyler F.

This place is amazing! We come in during our lunch break. Amazing pizza and it’s out quick. Staff is friendly definitely a 10/10.

The L. G.

Lunch I ordered a Buffalo chicken slice and a broccoli tomato slice. The dough was thick to hold the weight of the toppings, the chicken was half breaded and half grilled, when you bit into the breaded chicken it had a whole different taste and texture that wasn't all that good. You had chicken that had a different sauce flavor then what was put on the pizza. A splash of blue cheese would like to see more spread out. The broccoli and tomatoes were good just the cheese wasn't melted enough because of how it was blobs of cheese. The Atmosphere was ok like a clean pizza shop should have. 2 slices will run you $9 without drinks.

Dave K.

Decent pizza. Needs to be in the oven a little longer. Little more sauce too since the sauce was pretty good, but lacking in amount.

Robert M.

Muy bueno

Chuck D.

I tried a new (new to me I mean) Bucks county cheesesteak and I loved it!! If you haven't been in to Nico's yet in New Britain, you're cheating yourself. Ribeye with no gristle, a good amount of cooper sharp (not insane amounts to where it tastes like just cheese but nowhere near dry), small dice onions, and a toasted Liscio's seeded roll.

Also had a fantastic chicken cutlet sandwich called "the limoncello". This had burrata and an olive oil infused with lemon plus lemon zest. This was such a refreshing blend of flavors, just a really bright pop that I wasn't expecting! This may have been even better than the cheesesteak.

The wings I got made perfect sense for a pizza spot too. Picture crispy wings tossed in mild and bleu cheese then hit with fried cup and char pepperoni and hot honey. These were so unique, and I love trying new things. I'd get these again for sure!

Yeah...you'll want to find out for yourself on this one.

Keith E.

Fast service and delicious food. Portions are large and you will never leave hungry. Clean facility with plenty of seats and parking. Eggplant is superb. Chicken Caesar salad is plentiful and tasty. Very friendly team.

ThePhillyFoodFanatic

If you’re looking for authentic Italian food in New Britain, PA, Nico’s is the kind of restaurant that reminds you why family recipes will always beat trends. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel welcome, and the menu delivered a lineup of dishes that showcase both tradition and creativity.

We started with the homemade meatballs topped with creamy ricotta – tender, flavorful, and the perfect start to any meal. The Chicken Limoncello sandwich was a standout, with that bright lemon flavor cutting through every bite. The Eggplant Parmigiana served over pasta (a treasured recipe straight from the owner’s grandmother) tasted like Sunday dinner at nonna’s table. Their pasta in vodka sauce was velvety and rich, one of the best versions I’ve had in Bucks County.

Of course, it wouldn’t be Philly-area dining without a cheesesteak, and Nico’s puts a twist on it with Cooper Sharp cheese that takes it to another level. And then there’s the Bensonhurst pizza – perfectly crisp crust, plenty of cheese, and bold flavor that feels like Brooklyn brought to New Britain.

What makes Nico’s so special is the balance: you get classic Italian comfort food alongside creative takes, all made with care and fresh ingredients. Whether you’re in the mood for pizza, pasta, sandwiches, or parm, this spot has something to satisfy.

Nico’s is a must-visit restaurant in New Britain for Italian food lovers. Great for families, date nights, or anyone craving that homemade taste. I’ll definitely be back, and I highly recommend this hidden gem for locals and anyone searching for authentic Italian dining near Doylestown and Bucks County.

— ThePhillyFoodFanatic™

Stephanie B.

It’s always so nice coming to Nico’s. We used to live right around the corner but we’ve moved an hour away so now it’s a treat for us to come here. They give you such a familial feeling to everyone, regulars or one timers! The food is always amazing and the garlic knots are divine. If you haven’t been here and you’re thinking about it, I recommend 100%!